About a year and a half ago I wrote about John Marshall Law School Professor Colin Miller’s essay, Crossing Over: Why Attorneys (and Judges) Should Not be Able to Cross-Examine Witnesses Regarding Their Immigration Statuses for Impeachment Purposes, in which Miller argues that immigration status does not shed any light on a witness’s credibility, is more prejudicial than probative, and might implicate a witness’s Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination thanks to the growing criminalization of immigration law violations. In short, Miller thinks immigration status has no place in impeachment.
Now an article in the Texas Bar Journal follows Miller’s helpful article with a survey of case law from across the country—with a notable emphasis on Texas naturally. Professor Lupe Salinas from Texas Southern University Thurgood Marshall School of Law—and, I’m proud to say, a native of the Paloma barrio of McAllen—teamed up with Attorneys Benny Agosto, Jr. and Eloisa Morales Arteaga to describe state courts’ consistent hesitation to admit evidence of a witness’s undocumented status. In their article, But Your, Honor, He’s an Illegal! Can the Undocumented Worker’s Alien Status be Introduced at Trial, the trio explain that “courts are recognizing the prejudice that is engendered within the terms ‘illegal alien,’ ‘illegal immigrant,’ and ‘undocumented worker.’ These courts have tried to strike a balance between this prejudice and its possible relevance. Any relevance that the alien status of an injured worker may have in a particular case is likely outweighed by its prejudicial effect.”
Adding to the cases mentioned in these articles is a recent order from federal district court judge in the Western District of Missouri who excluded evidence of a criminal defendant’s status. The defendant argued that such evidence was not relevant to guilt or innocence and, even if it was, it was unduly prejudicial. United States v. Baldenegro-Valdez, No. 10-00094-02-CR-W-DGK, slip op. at 2 (W.D. Mo. Mar. 11, 2011) (Kays, J.).
This is a list that will only continue to grow.
Update (June 23, 2011): A New York court held that a plaintiff’s immigration status was properly excluded in a case involving a construction worker who fell two stories through an improperly covered hole in the roof of the defendant’s construction project. Angamarca v. New York City Partnership Housing, 2011 NY Slip Op. 5361, 2011 N.Y. App. Div. LEXIS 5251 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. June 21, 2011).
Braydon Prunty
Really informative blog. Really Great.
Addison Timmerman
Thank you for your post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
Domenic Placencia
Thank you ever so for you blog.Thanks Again. Cool.
Gloria Montenegro
Fantastic blog.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.
Hector Lucier
Really informative blog post.Much thanks again. Great.
Kathryn Stetson
I truly appreciate this blog article.Thanks Again. Really Great.
Keshawn Loeffler
I loved your blog.Really thank you! Will read on…
Reina Matherne
I think this is a real great blog.Much thanks again. Will read on…
Abagail Bolyard
A round of applause for your blog.Thanks Again. Will read on…
������������� �������
I really enjoy the article post.Really thank you! Cool.
Heaven Needham
I really enjoy the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
Kinley Ringo
Very neat blog article.Really thank you! Want more.
Alissa Scaggs
Say, you got a nice blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.
Ahmed Samples
I think this is a real great article post.Much thanks again. Great.
Annie Urbanski
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog.Thanks Again. Will read on…
Mutual Fund Investments
Great article.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
illinois vehicle auto insurance
Very neat article post. Keep writing.
Sophie Rippy
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic article post.Really thank you! Will read on…
Ellis Howlett
Muchos Gracias for your article.Thanks Again. Want more.
Emilee Kershner
Thanks a lot for the article post.Much thanks again. Awesome.
Cayden Updike
I think this is a real great post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.
Ashlee Duenas
Appreciate you sharing, great blog post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
Maura Alberto
Thanks a lot for the article.Much thanks again. Will read on…
Ally Robinson
Thanks-a-mundo for the article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
Braeden Pierce
Very neat post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
Elyse Rodriguez
I appreciate you sharing this blog post.Much thanks again. Cool.
Emmalee Hesson
I value the article post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
Johnny Birch
I cannot thank you enough for the blog post. Much obliged.
Kaitlyn Endres
Appreciate you sharing, great blog post.Thanks Again. Awesome.
Kelsie Exley
Hey, thanks for the blog article.Thanks Again. Cool.
Richard Marrero
wow, awesome article.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…
Kenyon Ressler
This is one awesome blog article.Thanks Again. Really Cool.
http://www.paydayday.co.uk/
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
nike pas cher
Air Jordan Basketball Shoes,Nike Air Jordan Basketball Shoes,Air Jordan Basketball Shoes Sale
car insurance young drivers
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
http://modafinilaustralia.webs.com
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
news ycombinator
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
FakE OaklEy FuEl CEll
What’s up everyone, I am sure you will be enjoying here by watching these kinds of hilarious video lessons.
chaussure nike tn
I like this post, enjoyed this one appreciate it for putting up.
Fake Oakley Holbrook
It going to be ending of mine day, but before end I am reading this enormous paragraph to increase my knowledge.
Fake Oakley Dispatch II
|When I wish for to place gallery or LightBox or even a slider on my web page I always try to use jQuery script for that.
Fake Oakley Sunglasses
I would like to comprehend when you write this article is what kind of mood, why would you write this article, also written so good, is that I can learn. I think I could record something like you.
Fake Oakleys
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
Cheap Oakley Dispatch
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
uggs outlet online
new kids ugg boots
kahpbthodpz
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
maillot entrainement psg
But your website is my way to wanted details, my problem is solved now. Many thanks for publishing something value readinga?|
http://www.neom.ca/bracelets-pandora.html
crImmigration.com: Admissibility of Immigration Status in Civil or Criminal Trials
maillot de football
Thanks i love your post about Why We Keep an eye on | J Squared Consulting