It took less than twenty-four hours before my brother Carlos Moctezuma García, one-half (along with my other brother Raúl) of García & García Law and patrocinador of this blog, fielded a question about whether last week’s Supreme Court decision holding that vehicle flight constitutes a violent felony under the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA) applies to the crime of violence type of aggravated felony. See Sykes v. United States, No. 09-11311, slip op. (June 9, 2011) (Kennedy wrote for Roberts, Breyer, Alito, Sotomayor; Thomas concurring in the judgment; Scalia dissented; Kagan dissented and Ginsburg joined). The likely answer is no.
It’s not a surprise that Sykes came onto the radar of some immigration law-minded folks. The ACCA imposes a serious sentencing enhancement if someone is convicted of being a felon in unlawful possession of a firearm after having been convicted of three previous violent felonies. 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(2). The ACCA defines “violent felony” in language that closely resembles the crime of violence definition used by the INA’s aggravated felony provision.
The ACCA defines violent felony as an offense punishable by at least one year of imprisonment and that “(i) has as an element the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against the person of another; or (ii) is burglary, arson, or extortion, involves use of explosives, or otherwise involves conduct that presents a serious potential risk of physical injury to another.” 18 U.S.C. § 924(e)(2)(B).
In comparison, INA § 101(a)(43)(F) defines a crime of violence by referencing 18 U.S.C. § 16 which, in turn, defines crime of violence as “(a) an offense that has as an element the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against the person or property of another, or (b) any other offense that is a felony and that, by its nature, involves a substantial risk that physical force against the person or property of another may be used in the course of committing the offense.”
While the first prong of the ACCA’s definition and the definition used by the INA are almost identical, there is greater difference between the second prongs of each definition. While the ACCA’s second prong requires that the offense “involve[] conduct that presents a serious potential risk of physical injury to another,” 18 U.S.C. § 924(e)(2)(B)(ii), the definition that the INA uses requires “substantial risk that physical force…may be used,” 18 U.S.C. § 16(b).
The key difference is in the focus of each definition. The ACCA focuses on the likelihood that someone will be injured as a result of committing the offense. Sykes, No. 09-11311, slip op. at 6 (“The question, then, is whether Indiana’s prohibition on flight from an officer by driving a vehicle…falls within the residual clause because, as a categorical matter, it presents a serious potential risk of physical injury to another.”).
In contrast, the INA’s chosen definition focuses on the substantial risk that physical risk will be used during commission of the crime. Leocal v. Ashcroft, 543 U.S. 1, 11 (2004) (“This is particularly true in light of §16(b)’s requirement that the ‘substantial risk’ be a risk of using physical force against another person ‘in the course of committing the offense.’”).
The Leocal Court explained this distinction with regard to the definition of crime of violence used in the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines, a definition that is nearly identical to the ACCA’s definition: “Thus, §16(b) plainly does not encompass all offenses which create a “substantial risk” that injury will result from a person’s conduct. The ‘substantial risk’ in §16(b) relates to the use of force, not to the possible effect of a person’s conduct.” Leocal v. Ashcroft, 543 U.S. 1, 10 n.7 (2004).
Because the Sykes Court was considering the ACCA definition, its holding can be read to mean only that vehicle flight necessarily “‘involves conduct that presents a serious potential risk of physical injury to another.’” Sykes, No. 09-11311, slip op. at 11 (quoting 18 U.S.C. § 942(e)(2)(B)(ii)). This does not necessarily mean that fleeing with the use of a vehicle also necessarily involves a substantial risk of using physical force. Compare United States v. Charles, 301 F.3d 309, 314 (5th Cir. 2002) (explaining that an offense is a crime of violence under the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines § 4B1.2(a)(2) definition if the crime “presents a serious potential risk of injury to a person”), with Brieva-Perez v. Gonzales, 482 F.3d 356, 360 (5th Cir. 2007) (“Charles…does not extend to § 16 crime of violence cases….”).
Two possible complications appear. First, the Sykes Court explained in dicta that “Risk of violence is inherent in vehicle flight.” Sykes, No. 09-11311, slip op. at 7. This statement conceivably could be used no matter what the definition of crime of violence that applies is concerned—the ACCA or INA.
In a similar vein, the Court later wrote, “Serious and substantial risks are an inherent part of vehicle flight.” Sykes, No. 09-11311, slip op. at 12. This “substantial risk” language resembles the language of 18 U.S.C. § 16(b). However, my reading of this sentence alongside the prior paragraph of the opinion suggests that the Court was referring to the substantial risk of bodily injury. Courts might disagree with me, but that’s what I take from the decision’s reference to “substantial risk of bodily injury to another” just three sentences earlier. Sykes, No. 09-11311, slip op. at 12.
So do you believe the ice will try to use this decision in deportation proceedings? It seems as if the ACCA definition and the INS definition is one in the same for them. In terms of the Begay test it seems the court has changed it to only be applicable for reckless Crimes how does this affect the governments utilization of determining which crimes have the elements of 18(b)?
payday loans
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
fast24hr-shorttermukloans.co.uk
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
Uk1312Monthloans.Co.uk
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
short term loans
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
short term loans
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://paydaynoloanshistoryonlinequickmh.co.uk/
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
bingo mobile
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
credit card consolidation loans
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://www.aboutecigarette.com
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
Donald Bernard
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
ecig
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
car valuation free
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
hgh joint pain
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
San Diego wedding photographer
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
car valuation formula
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
how to get your ex back magic of making up
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://www.sbwire.com/press-releases/wrelationshipcom-tells-visitors-how-to-get-their-ex-back-using-the-no-contact-rule-247419.htm
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://www.sbwire.com/press-releases/wrelationshipcom-tells-visitors-how-to-get-their-ex-back-using-the-no-contact-rule-247419.htm
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarette las vegas
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
garcinia pure
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
car insurance florida
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
7 keto at walmart
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
car valuation
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
hgh
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
donald bernard newark nj
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
Phentermine
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
hgh natural
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
where can I buy 7 keto
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
low t tribulus
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
7 keto kullananların yorumları
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
donald bernard mitchell
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
credit consolidation loans
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarette yukon ok
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
no contact rule
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
Donald Bernard
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
e cig
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
tramadol dosage for dogs
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
buy electronic cigarettes
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
tramadol online pharmacy
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
vapor cigarettes
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarettes queensland
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
provigil
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
buy tramadol
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
modafinil cost without insurance
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
smokeless cigarettes
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
garcinia cambogia extract
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
e-cigs
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
where to buy electronic cigarettes
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
best e cigarette 2013
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://cialis-italia.com
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
buy tramadol
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
vaporizer inhaler
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
modafinil purchase
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
smokeless cigarettes
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
lifelock locations
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
vaporizer xrt
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
garcinia
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
vapor cigarettes
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://www.databytez.com/
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
cialis leg pain
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarettes krave
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
vaporizer
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
london escorts
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
v2 cigs coupon
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarettes lexington ky
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://cialis-italia.com
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
garcinia pure
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
acquisto cialis
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
modafinil tim ferriss
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarettes during pregnancy
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarette accessories
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
modafinil vs armodafinil
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://ecigre.tumblr.com
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
provigil yahoo answers
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
london escort
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
lifelock promo code
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
buy modafinil
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
garcinia cambogia juice
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
escorts london
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
acquisto cialis
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://buyprovigil.webs.com
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
buy tramadol online
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
http://thevapechief.info
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
tramadol online
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
volcano vaporizer
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
modafinil
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
tramadol
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
cialis last longer
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
buy provigil online
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
vaporizer at walmart
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
modafinil usmle
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
christmas board game
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
provigil online
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
cialis vs viagra reviews
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
cialis que es
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
lifelock promotional code
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
xyrem provigil
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
website copywriting
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
green coffee maxx reviews
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
phentermine
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
board games
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
electronic cigarettes
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
dr david amron
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA
ray ban hipster glasses
crImmigration.com: SCOTUS: Vehicle flight is violent felony under ACCA