crimmigration.com

The intersection of criminal law and immigration law

Archive

After regularly updating crimmigration.com from January 2009 until November 2022, I have stopped doing so. I hope you continue to benefit from the blog as an archive. For up-to-date information about my work, visit ccgarciahernandez.com. – César

  • Home
  • About César
  • Articles
  • Books
  • Talks & Media

Symposium: Moncrieffe and the Categorical Approach

By Patty Corrales, former Senior Attorney for ICE

I just got back from my son’s soccer game. It was very intense. These ten year old boys were playing hard as a team to score a goal understanding what they needed to do and what they couldn’t do within the confines of the rules of soccer. As a mom, I was totally into the game and I, like the other parents, was at the edge of my seat. Not only were the boys dripping with sweat from the heat of the afternoon but they were sweating with anticipation of winning the game and they just needed one goal.

It was the fourth quarter and my son, the sweeper on the team, got the ball. He was dribbling the ball. He was focused and in zone. He kept dribbling the ball and passed it to his friend who passed it back to my son. My son kept dribbling the ball and then got the ball centered to kick it into the goal. He kicked the ball and the ball got past the goalie. My son made the winning goal…we cheered and then we heard the referee’s whistle. The referee called my son “off sides” and so the goal didn’t count. The dads were pissed.

If you know anything about soccer, you know that “off sides” means the same in whatever soccer league you play in. Its meaning is historical and its application is intended to lead to fairness and predictability on the soccer field. But when a referee decides to interpret “off sides” differently and apply it in contrast to what the rules in soccer intended, then parents are going to call “foul.” It’s just not fair and not how “off sides” was intended to apply.

This might come as a surprise to many but as a former prosecutor for the State of Colorado and as a former Senior Attorney for ICE the last 17 years, I am shouting foul with the Fifth’s Circuit decision in Moncrieffe and the Government’s non categorical approach in that case. The Government decided to change the rules but didn’t give Mr. Moncrieffe the benefit of notifying him that the rules were going to change.

I am a believer in fairness. I am a believer in justice. If a prosecutor can prove that a defendant committed a crime beyond a reasonable doubt then obtaining a guilty verdict is fair and just. If the Department of Homeland Security can establish by clear and convincing evidence that an alien is removable for having been convicted of an aggravated felony then a finding of removability is fair and just. But, it is not fair or just when the burden of proof and who has that burden changes and it is not fair or just when the rules of the game change without proper notice. When that happens then it doesn’t matter what hat you are wearing, the need to call foul is important.

This week the Supreme Court is going to play referee in deciding the proper application of the “categorical approach.”  The high court is going to play an important role in an intense debate on ensuring that the immigration consequences on criminal convictions are comprehensible, reasonable and predictable. The real question that I believe Moncrieffe v. Holder, and likewise Garcia v. Holder, No. 11-79, represents is whether it is the government’s burden to establish that an alien has been convicted of an aggravated felony or whether the burden of both proof and persuasion falls on an alien to proof that he or she has not been convicted of an aggravated felony, particularly when the record of conviction is silent on salient facts that would make a state conviction an aggravated felony for immigration purposes.

Essentially, when a defendant is convicted in state court of possession of marijuana with intent to distribute but the record of conviction does not disclose the quantity of marijuana or the existence of remuneration, is the defendant removable as an alien who has been convicted of an “aggravated felony” merely because of the possibility that the amount of marijuana was not a small amount and that there was remuneration involved?  Who has to prove what and what approach is taken to determine whether the proper proof has been presented?

In Moncrieffe, the Fifth Circuit held that the petitioner bore the burden of proving that his conviction involved only a small amount of marijuana for no remuneration but that he had not offered any evidence on the matter in immigration court so the Court of Appeals sustained the finding of the Immigration Judge that Moncrieffe was removable as an aggravated felon.

This non-categorical approach urged by the Government places the burden of proof and persuasion on individuals like Moncrieffe, and the Board of Immigration Appeals (“Board”) is in agreement. Subsequent to filing the writ of certiorari in this case, the Board issued a precedential decision making clear that an alien has the opportunity in immigration court to show that section 21 U.S.C. § 841(b)(4)’s mitigating exception applies. See Matter of Castro-Rodriguez, 25 I&N Dec. 698, 702 (BIA 2012) (citing, inter alia, Nijhawan v. Holder, 557 U.S. 29 (2009)). So, it’s all left in the hands of the alien.

I find this interesting given that in this country when the Government charges you with a crime or attempts to remove you from this country, isn’t it their burden to proof to prove you committed the crime or that non-citizen alien should be removed from this country?

In the established terminology, the requirement of proof beyond a reasonable doubt in criminal cases was given constitutional status by the Supreme Court in 1970 in the case of In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358 (1970), which held that the Due Process Clause protects the accused against conviction except upon proof beyond a reasonable doubt of every fact necessary to constitute the crime with which he is being charged. The purpose behind this rule is simply because the Government has more access to the evidence necessary to prove the crime than a defendant may have to prove his innocence.

In removal cases, the parties’ burden of proof depends on whether the alien is an “applicant for admission” or has been admitted to the United States. Regardless, of whether the removal proceeding involves an alien’s deportation or admissibility, the U.S. government, and specifically DHS, must first establish by “clear, unequivocal, and convincing evidence” that you, as the person in question, are in fact an alien. The “clear and convincing” burden requires a showing that it is substantially more likely than not, as shown by the facts and evidence, that the person is an alien and that the person is removable from the United States for the immigration violation charged.

This burden of proof is higher than that in ordinary civil cases, where the burden is by the “preponderance of the evidence,” but lower than that in criminal cases, where the burden is “beyond a reasonable doubt.”  Nonetheless, the burden is on the Government. Why? Again, because the Government has more access to the evidence to establish the removability of an alien than the alien has access to proof that he or she is not removable from the United States.

Ultimately, Congress thought that the burden rests on the Government. This is no bold idea or approach. On the contrary, the non-categorical approach of the Fifth Circuit’s decision and that is advocated by the Government is bold and I hope the Supreme Court will call foul.

  • Share via Facebook
  • Share via LinkedIn
  • Share via Twitter
  • Share via Email

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Posted by César on October 9, 2012 on 9:00 am 90 Comments
Filed Under: aggravated felony, guest blogger, illicit trafficking, Scholars Sidebar, Symposium, U.S. Supreme Court

Comments

  1. Joaquin says

    October 9, 2012 at 6:44 pm

    As an immigration attorney for the last 20 years, it is very refreshing to know that Government attorneys, or former Governmental attorneys, like Ms. Corrales desire fairness and justice and that it is not about winning a case.

    Reply
  2. free new no deposit casino bonus codes on http://nodepositcasinocodes.webs.com says

    October 27, 2012 at 1:15 am

    no deposit casino bonus codes

    no deposit casino bonus codes

    Reply
  3. fare soldi online a comefaresoldi.webstarts.com rftz says

    October 30, 2012 at 6:32 pm

    come fare soldi facili

    come fare soldi facili

    Reply
  4. fare soldi facili ldji says

    October 30, 2012 at 10:14 pm

    http://comefaresoldi.webstarts.com

    http://comefaresoldi.webstarts.com

    Reply
  5. casino bonus a casinobonussenzadeposito.weebly.com senza deposito xflg says

    October 31, 2012 at 6:43 pm

    casino bonus senza deposito

    casino bonus senza deposito

    Reply
  6. casino italiano bonus gratis japy says

    October 31, 2012 at 7:30 pm

    http://casinobonussenzadeposito.weebly.com

    http://casinobonussenzadeposito.weebly.com

    Reply
  7. casino bonus senza deposito casinobonussenzadeposito.weebly.com bonus gratis wxbq says

    October 31, 2012 at 11:31 pm

    casino senza deposito

    casino senza deposito

    Reply
  8. casino bonus a freepokies.proboards.com play free pokies lqlj says

    November 1, 2012 at 6:16 pm

    pokies

    pokies

    Reply
  9. free pokies download gtlb says

    November 1, 2012 at 7:05 pm

    http://freepokies.proboards.com

    http://freepokies.proboards.com

    Reply
  10. http://freepokies.proboards.com - free pokies download dqee says

    November 1, 2012 at 8:29 pm

    free pokies

    free pokies

    Reply
  11. http://freepokies.proboards.com - free pokies download dqee says

    November 1, 2012 at 8:29 pm

    free pokies

    free pokies

    Reply
  12. http://freepokies.proboards.com - free pokies download dqee says

    November 1, 2012 at 8:29 pm

    free pokies

    free pokies

    Reply
  13. http://freepokies.proboards.com - free pokies download dqee says

    November 1, 2012 at 8:29 pm

    free pokies

    free pokies

    Reply
  14. http://freepokies.proboards.com - free pokies download dqee says

    November 1, 2012 at 8:29 pm

    free pokies

    free pokies

    Reply
  15. casino bonus senza deposito freepokies.proboards.com free pokies games downloads xclp says

    November 1, 2012 at 11:56 pm

    free pokies games

    free pokies games

    Reply
  16. slot machine online gratis furk says

    November 2, 2012 at 10:39 pm

    http://slotmachinedabar.altervista.org

    http://slotmachinedabar.altervista.org

    Reply
  17. slot machine bar gartis a slotmachinedabar.altervista.org senza scaricare coui says

    November 2, 2012 at 11:30 pm

    slot machine da bar gratis

    slot machine da bar gratis

    Reply
  18. slot machine gratis online da bar a http://slotmachinedabar.altervista.org dznp says

    November 3, 2012 at 12:57 am

    slot machine bar gratis

    slot machine bar gratis

    Reply
  19. slot machine gratis online da bar a http://slotmachinedabar.altervista.org dznp says

    November 3, 2012 at 12:57 am

    slot machine bar gratis

    slot machine bar gratis

    Reply
  20. slot machine gratis online da bar a http://slotmachinedabar.altervista.org dznp says

    November 3, 2012 at 12:57 am

    slot machine bar gratis

    slot machine bar gratis

    Reply
  21. slot machine gratis online da bar a http://slotmachinedabar.altervista.org dznp says

    November 3, 2012 at 12:57 am

    slot machine bar gratis

    slot machine bar gratis

    Reply
  22. slot machine gratis online da bar a http://slotmachinedabar.altervista.org dznp says

    November 3, 2012 at 12:57 am

    slot machine bar gratis

    slot machine bar gratis

    Reply
  23. slot machine bar gartis a slotmachinedabar.altervista.org senza scaricare daqv says

    November 3, 2012 at 1:46 am

    slot machine da bar gratis

    slot machine da bar gratis

    Reply
  24. casino bonus a remionline.webstarts.com sans depot hyjg says

    November 4, 2012 at 11:42 pm

    remi online

    remi online

    Reply
  25. remi royal gratis online vtvj says

    November 5, 2012 at 12:37 am

    http://remionline.webstarts.com

    http://remionline.webstarts.com

    Reply
  26. http://remionline.webstarts.com - remi online gratis pqun says

    November 5, 2012 at 2:07 am

    remi online

    remi online

    Reply
  27. http://remionline.webstarts.com - remi online gratis pqun says

    November 5, 2012 at 2:07 am

    remi online

    remi online

    Reply
  28. http://remionline.webstarts.com - remi online gratis pqun says

    November 5, 2012 at 2:07 am

    remi online

    remi online

    Reply
  29. http://remionline.webstarts.com - remi online gratis pqun says

    November 5, 2012 at 2:07 am

    remi online

    remi online

    Reply
  30. http://remionline.webstarts.com - remi online gratis pqun says

    November 5, 2012 at 2:07 am

    remi online

    remi online

    Reply
  31. remi royal gratis online yjsl says

    November 5, 2012 at 2:59 am

    http://remionline.webstarts.com

    http://remionline.webstarts.com

    Reply
  32. casino bonus a casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com ilman talletusta donp says

    November 14, 2012 at 8:37 pm

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    Reply
  33. netticasino bonus ilman talletusta pavy says

    November 14, 2012 at 9:32 pm

    http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com

    http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com

    Reply
  34. http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com - casino ilman talletusta zpyf says

    November 14, 2012 at 11:02 pm

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    Reply
  35. http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com - casino ilman talletusta zpyf says

    November 14, 2012 at 11:02 pm

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    Reply
  36. http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com - casino ilman talletusta zpyf says

    November 14, 2012 at 11:02 pm

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    Reply
  37. http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com - casino ilman talletusta zpyf says

    November 14, 2012 at 11:02 pm

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    Reply
  38. http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com - casino ilman talletusta zpyf says

    November 14, 2012 at 11:02 pm

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    casino bonus ilman talletusta

    Reply
  39. netticasino bonus ilman talletusta dvmz says

    November 14, 2012 at 11:54 pm

    http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com

    http://casinobonusilmantalletusta.webstarts.com

    Reply
  40. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis jtmr says

    November 20, 2012 at 12:45 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  41. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis jtmr says

    November 20, 2012 at 12:45 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  42. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis jtmr says

    November 20, 2012 at 12:45 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  43. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis jtmr says

    November 20, 2012 at 12:45 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  44. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis jtmr says

    November 20, 2012 at 12:45 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  45. slot machine bar gratis italy loxd says

    November 20, 2012 at 1:46 am

    slotmachinebar.weebly.com

    slotmachinebar.weebly.com

    Reply
  46. slot machine online gratis da bar igmt says

    November 20, 2012 at 3:33 am

    http://slotmachinebar.weebly.com

    http://slotmachinebar.weebly.com

    Reply
  47. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis ysva says

    November 20, 2012 at 4:34 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  48. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis ysva says

    November 20, 2012 at 4:34 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  49. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis ysva says

    November 20, 2012 at 4:34 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  50. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis ysva says

    November 20, 2012 at 4:34 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  51. slotmachinebar.weebly.com - slot machine da bar gratis ysva says

    November 20, 2012 at 4:34 am

    slot machine bar

    slot machine bar

    Reply
  52. gratis spilleautomater a www.charterschoolpolicy.org i norge paoj says

    December 3, 2012 at 10:19 pm

    spilleautomater p� nett

    spilleautomater p� nett

    Reply
  53. gratis spilleautomater a www.charterschoolpolicy.org i norge paoj says

    December 3, 2012 at 10:19 pm

    spilleautomater p� nett

    spilleautomater p� nett

    Reply
  54. gratis spilleautomater a www.charterschoolpolicy.org i norge paoj says

    December 3, 2012 at 10:19 pm

    spilleautomater p� nett

    spilleautomater p� nett

    Reply
  55. gratis spilleautomater a www.charterschoolpolicy.org i norge paoj says

    December 3, 2012 at 10:19 pm

    spilleautomater p� nett

    spilleautomater p� nett

    Reply
  56. gratis spilleautomater a www.charterschoolpolicy.org i norge paoj says

    December 3, 2012 at 10:19 pm

    spilleautomater p� nett

    spilleautomater p� nett

    Reply
  57. spilleautomater p� nett spilleautomater i norge zdfw says

    December 3, 2012 at 11:30 pm

    http://www.charterschoolpolicy.org

    http://www.charterschoolpolicy.org

    Reply
  58. gratis spilleautomater i norge p� nett tdlz says

    December 4, 2012 at 1:34 am

    http://www.charterschoolpolicy.org

    http://www.charterschoolpolicy.org

    Reply
  59. spilleautomater p� nett spilleautomater i norge lgjn says

    December 4, 2012 at 2:39 am

    http://www.charterschoolpolicy.org

    http://www.charterschoolpolicy.org

    Reply
  60. casino aams online a casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com smqh says

    December 7, 2012 at 9:58 pm

    casino aams

    casino aams

    Reply
  61. casino aams online a casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com lfwz says

    December 7, 2012 at 11:02 pm

    casino aams

    casino aams

    Reply
  62. casino online aams http://casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com oamg says

    December 8, 2012 at 12:59 am

    casino online

    casino online

    Reply
  63. http://casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com - casino aams fywr says

    December 8, 2012 at 2:02 am

    casino online aams

    casino online aams

    Reply
  64. http://casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com - casino aams fywr says

    December 8, 2012 at 2:02 am

    casino online aams

    casino online aams

    Reply
  65. http://casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com - casino aams fywr says

    December 8, 2012 at 2:02 am

    casino online aams

    casino online aams

    Reply
  66. http://casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com - casino aams fywr says

    December 8, 2012 at 2:02 am

    casino online aams

    casino online aams

    Reply
  67. http://casinoonlineaams.webstarts.com - casino aams fywr says

    December 8, 2012 at 2:02 am

    casino online aams

    casino online aams

    Reply
  68. casino ohne einzahlung casinoohneeinzahlung.webs.com boni casinos mipe says

    December 19, 2012 at 12:37 am

    casino bonus ohne einzahlung

    casino bonus ohne einzahlung

    Reply
  69. casino bonus ohne einzahlung tuat says

    December 19, 2012 at 1:38 am

    casinoohneeinzahlung.webs.com

    casinoohneeinzahlung.webs.com

    Reply
  70. online casino ohne einzahlung fzfg says

    December 19, 2012 at 3:22 am

    http://casinoohneeinzahlung.webs.com

    http://casinoohneeinzahlung.webs.com

    Reply
  71. casino bonus ohne einzahlung rayx says

    December 19, 2012 at 4:20 am

    casinoohneeinzahlung.webs.com

    casinoohneeinzahlung.webs.com

    Reply
  72. Check Out www.cheap49ersjerseyshop.com says

    December 21, 2012 at 7:30 am

    Check Out http://www.cheap49ersjerseyshop.com

    crImmigration.com: Symposium: Moncrieffe and the Categorical Approach

    Reply
  73. click through the following post says

    December 22, 2012 at 10:43 am

    click through the following post

    crImmigration.com: Symposium: Moncrieffe and the Categorical Approach

    Reply
  74. casino ohne einzahlung casinoohneeinzahlung.tumblr.com boni casinos tvnb says

    December 25, 2012 at 1:21 am

    casino bonus ohne einzahlung

    casino bonus ohne einzahlung

    Reply
  75. casino bonus ohne einzahlung kfpd says

    December 25, 2012 at 2:42 am

    casinoohneeinzahlung.tumblr.com

    casinoohneeinzahlung.tumblr.com

    Reply
  76. online casino ohne einzahlung nrui says

    December 25, 2012 at 5:04 am

    http://casinoohneeinzahlung.tumblr.com

    http://casinoohneeinzahlung.tumblr.com

    Reply
  77. casino bonus ohne einzahlung dbcz says

    December 25, 2012 at 6:18 am

    casinoohneeinzahlung.tumblr.com

    casinoohneeinzahlung.tumblr.com

    Reply
  78. online geld im internet http://www.geldverdieneniminternet.tv verdinen geld im internet tzyq says

    January 4, 2013 at 5:45 pm

    geld verdienen

    geld verdienen

    Reply
  79. online geld verdienen im internet http://www.geldverdieneniminternet.tv geld verdienen von zu hause says

    January 4, 2013 at 8:29 pm

    geld verdienen serios

    geld verdienen serios

    Reply
  80. online geld im internet http://www.geldverdieneniminternet.tv geld im internet ewrn says

    January 5, 2013 at 1:00 am

    geld verdienen von zu hause

    geld verdienen von zu hause

    Reply
  81. geld verdienen im internet geld verdienen online cbut says

    January 5, 2013 at 3:32 am

    geld verdienen im internet casino

    geld verdienen im internet casino

    Reply
  82. click here says

    January 12, 2013 at 11:26 pm

    click here

    crImmigration.com: Symposium: Moncrieffe and the Categorical Approach

    Reply
  83. slot machine bar a http://slotmachinebar.webstarts.com says

    January 31, 2013 at 3:47 am

    slot machine gratis da bar

    slot machine gratis da bar

    Reply
  84. slot machine online gratis da bar says

    January 31, 2013 at 5:04 am

    http://slotmachinebar.webstarts.com

    http://slotmachinebar.webstarts.com

    Reply
  85. slotmachinebar.webstarts.com - slot machine bar says

    January 31, 2013 at 7:26 am

    slot machine da bar gratis

    slot machine da bar gratis

    Reply
  86. slot machine da bar online a http://slotmachinebar.webstarts.com says

    January 31, 2013 at 8:38 am

    slot machine

    slot machine

    Reply
  87. payday loans uk says

    May 7, 2013 at 5:21 am

    payday loans uk

    I can’t figure out how do I subscribe for your blog

    Reply
  88. Cheap Oakley frogskins says

    July 9, 2013 at 10:54 am

    Cheap Oakley frogskins

    It an amazing post in favor of all the internet people; they will take advantage from it I am sure.

    Reply
  89. Ray Ban Sunglasses Sale says

    July 12, 2013 at 1:31 pm

    Ray Ban Sunglasses Sale

    These are truly cool YouTube video clips, its my luck to visit this web page and finding such cool YouTube movies.

    Reply
  90. Oakley Eyepatch Sunglasses says

    July 21, 2013 at 5:51 pm

    Oakley Eyepatch Sunglasses

    Ahaa, its fastidious discussion on the topic of this piece of writing at this place at this weblog, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting here.

    Reply

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe


Recent Posts

  • Pelosi attacker reportedly Canadian overstayer
  • Biden marijuana pardon meets immigration law & fizzles
  • California private prison ban is illegal, 9th Circuit says
  • Citizenship is complicated
  • Supreme Court says Biden can end MPP
  • Uvalde massacre & immigration law aid

Search

Social Media

Blawg 100 Honoree

The information contained on these pages must not be considered legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. This work by www.crImmigration.com is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.