crimmigration.com

The intersection of criminal law and immigration law

BIA: LPR seeks admission if caught engaging in illegal activity at port of entry

Guest Blogger Tamikka Pate

Recently, the Board of Immigration Appeals held that a lawful permanent resident of the United States may be treated as an applicant for admission, pursuant to INA § 101(a)(13)(C)(iii), in removal proceedings if the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) proves by clear and convincing evidence that the returning resident engaged in “illegal activity” at a United States port of entry. Matter of Martinez, 25 I&N Dec. 845, 848 (BIA 2012).

Respondent Ignacio Guzman Martinez, a native and citizen of Mexico, has been a lawful permanent resident of the United States since 2004. Id. at 845. After returning from Mexico in mid-July 2005, Martinez arrived at the San Ysidro, California, port of entry for inspection. Id. There, immigration officers determined that Martinez was attempting to bring an undocumented juvenile alien into the United States in violation of § 212(a)(6)(E)(i) of the INA, as an alien who “at any time knowingly has encouraged, induced, assisted, abetted, or aided any other alien to enter or to try to enter the United States in violation of law.” Id. at 845-46. Accordingly, Martinez was paroled into the United States and removal proceedings were initiated charging Martinez as inadmissible. Id.

The immigration judge, after several evidentiary hearings, dismissed the charge and terminated the removal proceedings “without prejudice,” concluding that the notice to appear had been “improvidently issued” by the DHS. In particular, the IJ determined that the decision to charge the respondent with inadmissibility was inconsistent with § 101(a)(13)(C) of the Act because § 101(a)(13)(C) establishes a rebuttable presumption that returning lawful permanent residents “shall not be regarded as seeking an admission into the United States for purposes of the immigration laws.” Id. at 846.

On appeal, DHS argued that the notice to appear was not improvidently issued and that the evidence was sufficient to rebut the statutory presumption against treating a returning lawful permanent resident as an applicant for admission. Id. The presumption may be rebutted if the DHS establishes by clear and convincing evidence that one or more of six statutory exceptions apply. Id. (citing Matter of Rivens, 25 I&N Dec. 623 (BIA 2011)).

DHS then invoked the exception in § 101(a)(13)(C)(iii) of the Act, which authorizes a returning lawful permanent resident to be regarded as an applicant for admission if he “has engaged in illegal activity after having departed the United States.” Id. Subsequently, the Board discussed the various meanings and scope of “illegal activity,” but ultimately decided that it “need not define the outer limits of the term in this case” because there is no “serious dispute that the conduct alleged here – knowingly attempting to bring an undocumented alien into the United States – is ‘illegal activity’ under any reasonable construction.” Id. at 846-47.

The Board acknowledged the immigration judge’s reading of § 101(a)(13)(C)(iii) as applying only to illegal activity engaged in abroad or on the high seas, but not to activity committed during inspection at a United States port of entry; however, the Board disagreed. The Board stated that there is no dispute that illegal activity committed by a returning lawful permanent resident after his lawful entry into the United States would not trigger application of § 101(a)(13)(C)(iii), because in such a case the offending conduct would have occurred while the lawful permanent resident was “in and admitted” to the United States, thereby making the lawful permanent resident subject to deportation. Id.

But the “same cannot be said of a returning lawful permanent resident who engages in illegal activity while undergoing inspection at a port of entry” the Board determined, because although the illegal activity alleged here may have been discovered at the port of entry, that does not mean it began there. Id. at 848. Thus, according to the Board, the most natural reading of § 101(a)(13)(C)(iii) is that it “covers any alien who engages in illegal activity after departing from the United States but before reentering after inspection.” Id.


Tamikka Pate is a third-year student at Capital University Law School with an interest in racial justice.

Comments

  12. asics nimbus 14

    We really do look forward to your posts, thanks to you!you are really a nice webmaster, you have done a well job on this topic!I am very impress your this post, this is too much interesting. Thanks a lot…Not bad. Some more detail would be even better.The both. much more of an effort with regards tell you on something.I am thankful for you featuring this fact inside your webpage

    Reply

  15. gucci handbag sale

    hi!,I really like your writing so much! share we keep in touch extra approximately your post on AOL? I need an expert on this space to unravel my problem. May be that’s you! Taking a look ahead to look you.

    Reply

  16. chanel 255

    I really liked this post. You write about this topic very well. Optimized content will help drive your site’s credibility and link building will add page rank to improve your placement on search results pages. Existing web sites in all industry segments will benefit from optimization, driving more traffic through organic placement and links.

    Reply

  17. gucci online

    Believe it or not, I was actually thinking about you (in a non-creepy way, I swear) just a few weeks ago, wondering how you were and if I had somehow missed a post. Glad to see you back to form, and looking forward to reading whatever comes next!

    Reply

  19. chanel canada

    In particular, the two women Jordan shoes, Jordan shoes business, are perfect for today’s people, we who admire the true body exercise, but do not need to invest more than that a great offer it.

    Reply

  23. authentic chanel bags

    How to you destroy the left-hand general he smash me up to much and I want to find a way to kill him but it was to hard I am lv 28 and tell me what lv is the left hand general and right hand general

    Reply

  27. learn spanish online

    get dressed together with the certain Htc bravo situated James Gunn’s Individual guideline just for Layout not to mention very first contemporary recognized you can find at Liz Claiborne.

    Reply

  29. best music production software

    I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own blog and was wondering what all is needed to get set up? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? I’m not very web smart so I’m not 100% sure. Any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated. Cheers

    Reply

  33. learn portuguese

    I really enjoy the following Dragon’s prophet gold and it’s hopefully finding my personal Dragon’s prophet gold. I will choose to pay attention to the price tag dropped to adore $120 i received wallbes and then they were definitely basically $105, hence make sure you generate all these Dragon’s prophet gold somewhat more affordable!

    Reply

  35. feminine tattoo designs

    Wow, wonderful blog format! How lengthy with been weblogs for? people make weblogs look fuss-free. The over-all glance within your web blog is really good, to fail to this piece of content material!

    Reply

  36. singing lessons

    Thanks when planning on taking a few momemts to uncertainty this, Seriously considered feel strongly to correct it and truly love learning added on in which topic. Must doable, once you achieve come across, would a lot of people thoughts updating your website with added info? This is helpful within my circumstances.

    Reply

  37. learn to speak japanese

    小王是推销员，因为工作特别忙，一个星期有五天不在家，自然对太太有所歉意，想利用整个周末补偿她！这个星期日，正当他们在那张会嘎嘎做响的床上亲热时 忽然！！隔壁的老太太用力敲着墙壁，大喊着：你们有完没完！！！一个星期有七天！你们就不能休息一天吗？

    Reply

  40. learn hindi online

    But if Deckers UGG boots lose their luster with affluent customers, lowering the price won be very helpful in generating more revenue. Across the globe, the middle class has been shrinking. Even a discounted pair of UGG boots will still be more expensive than lowend apparel offerings so it unclear exactly who Deckers would be targeting if it lowered prices to increase demand.

    Reply

  41. glow in the dark pigment

    g. Moreover, there were occasional discrepancies of sufficient magnitude and duration which may limit the clinical usefulness of the N-CAT in patients in whom continuous and accurate blood pressure measurement is required.

    Reply

  43. glow products

    Out of question, when you wear a Cartier watch perfectly combining with shinning diamonds, you will instantly become eye-catcher and win so much envy very soon. I do take a great interest in jewelry Cartier watches and one of my dreams was to purchase them some day. I never thought that I could enjoy noted watches until I met replica watches for sale. On the Internet, I accidently found out Cartier replica and its excellence did bring me surprise. Looking at replica watches online carefully and checking every detail, I eventually got an imitation watch. A year has passed and now I am still using my fake designer watch. I have to say, my Cartier replica jewelry watch is good enough.

    Reply

  45. learn japanese online free

    I’m not sure where you’re getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for great info I was looking for this info for my mission.

    Reply

  46. learn hebrew online

    855 I don’t have a 70 inch moose rack in the wall, but I contemplate my smaller sized moose as trophies however. But I discovered out in the present day that it’s the Louis Vuitton watches possessing a little more diamonds and becoming alot more high-class.

    Reply

  48. learn japanese online free

    I’ve been browsing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. Personally, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be much more useful than ever before.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.