crimmigration.com

The intersection of criminal law and immigration law

  • Home
  • About César
  • Articles
  • Books
  • Book Tour
  • Talks & Media

Fla Supreme Ct: Padilla not retroactive; admonishment doesn’t cure bad advice

The Florida Supreme Court held that Padilla v. Kentucky, 130 S. Ct. 1473 (2010), does not apply retroactively and that a trial court’s admonishment to a criminal defendant about the possible immigration repercussions of conviction doesn’t necessarily cure a defense attorney’s deficient performance. Hernandez v. State, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. (Fla. Nov. 21, 2012) (Polston, Lewis, Quince, Canady, Labarga, and Perry, JJ.; Pariente concurs).

The court began by noting, without explanation, that Hernández’s conviction for sale of a controlled substance constitutes a controlled substances offense and drug trafficking type of aggravated felony. Hernandez, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. at 8. As such, it was clear to the court that removal was presumptively mandatory, thus Hernández’s plea-stage attorney was required to have advised him of that. Because the attorney only told Hernández “that a plea could/may affect [Hernandez’s] immigration status,” the attorney did not do as required by Padilla. Hernandez, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. at 9. Consequently, the attorney provided deficient performance.

Moving onto the ineffective assistance of counsel’s prejudice prong, the court rejected the state’s argument that the defense attorney’s deficient performance was cured by the trial court’s warning, pursuant to a state rule of criminal procedure, Fla. Rule of Crim. Proc. 3.172(c)(8), that pleading guilty or nolo contendere “may subject him or her to deportation.” Hernandez, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. at 9. The admonishment doesn’t cure the defense attorney’s deficiency, the court explained, because its warning is more “equivocal” than Padilla requires “[w]here deportation consequences are ‘truly clear.’” Hernandez, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. at 10.

Having determined that Hernández had a viable Padilla claim, the court then turned to whether Padilla even applies to him given that his conviction long preceded the Supreme Court’s decision. The court decided that it does not.

Under Florida law, a criminal procedure rule applies only prospectively unless it “‘(a) emanates from this Court or the United States Supreme Court, (b) is constitutional in nature, and (c) constitutes a development of fundamental significance.’” Hernandez, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. at 11 (quoting Chandler v. Crosby, 916 So. 2d 728, 729 (Fla. 2005)). Clearly Padilla meets the first two requirements so the only question before the court was whether it’s “fundamental,” which Chandler explained means it “places beyond the authority of the state the power to regulate certain conduct or impose certain penalties or when the rule is of sufficient magnitude to necessitate retroactive application.” Hernandez, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. at 12 (Chandler, 916 So. at 729). The second option has somewhat of a circular bent since it seems to define a rule of criminal procedure as fundamental when it is sufficiently important to merit retroactive application. The court didn’t see it that way, however.

Instead, it proceeded to explore whether Padilla is of sufficient magnitude to merit retroactive application, a three-factor assessment that considers: “(a) the purpose to be served by the new rule; (b) the extent of the reliance on the old rule; and (c) the effect on the administration of justice of a retroactive application of the new rule.” Hernandez, No. SC 11-941 & SC 11-1357, slip op. at 12. None of these factors, the court concluded, were met. Accordingly, the court concluded that Padilla doesn’t apply retroactively to Florida convictions.

Without question this is tough news for noncitizens with Florida convictions. DHS’s emphasis on targeting “criminal aliens,” including folks with old convictions, suggests that many more people will find themselves in removal proceedings due to convictions that became final long before Padilla was announced.

The saving grace for defendants with convictions from other jurisdictions is that Florida uses a different retroactivity standard from the federal courts and the many states that have adopted the federal standard announced in Teague v. Lane, 489 U.S. 288 (1989). Of course, we’ll see what the U.S. Supreme Court decides about retroactivity under Teague when it issues its decision in Chaidez v. United States, No. 11-820 this winter or spring (an online symposium containing detailed analyses of Chaidez is available here. Michael Vastine, an immigration law professor at St. Thomas University, argued Hernandez and contributed to the Chaidez symposium.

  • Share via Facebook
  • Share via LinkedIn
  • Share via Twitter
  • Share via Email

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Posted by César on January 22, 2013 on 9:00 am 17 Comments
Filed Under: Chaidez, Florida state court, Padilla v. Kentucky, post-conviction relief, right to counsel, state court

Comments

  1. hiburan anak says

    January 31, 2013 at 5:33 am

    hiburan anak

    crImmigration.com: Fla Supreme Ct: Padilla not retroactive; admonishment doesn’t cure bad advice

    Reply
  2. pilgrim jewellery wholesale says

    March 22, 2013 at 4:02 am

    pilgrim jewellery wholesale

    crImmigration.com: Fla Supreme Ct: Padilla not retroactive; admonishment doesn’t cure bad advice

    Reply
  3. epson printer ink t0715 says

    March 25, 2013 at 3:07 am

    epson printer ink t0715

    crImmigration.com: Fla Supreme Ct: Padilla not retroactive; admonishment doesn’t cure bad advice

    Reply
  4. nike air max sale says

    April 9, 2013 at 4:32 am

    nike air max sale

    The café remained closed, though the yellow police tape was removed late in the dayThe café remained closed, though the yellow police tape was removed late in the day. We have done that job, Golborne said We have done that job, Golborne said.

    Reply
  5. payday loans says

    April 27, 2013 at 12:12 am

    payday loans

    That you are my function designs. Many thanks for the write-up

    Reply
  6. online casino says

    April 27, 2013 at 3:51 am

    online casino

    crImmigration.com: Fla Supreme Ct: Padilla not retroactive; admonishment doesn’t cure bad advice

    Reply
  7. oakley outlet says

    June 25, 2013 at 4:19 am

    oakley outlet

    What a pleasant YouTube video it is! Remarkable, I liked it, and I am sharing this YouTube film with all my friends.

    Reply
  8. Divorce & Family Law says

    June 26, 2013 at 10:09 am

    Divorce & Family Law

    Our builder is wanting in order to influence us to advance for you to .internet from PHP. We have often disliked the thought because of the costs. But he’s tryiong not one your less. I have been employing Hubpages on the various websites for about a year and also feel worried about moving over to a different platform.

    Reply
  9. Divorce & Family Law says

    June 26, 2013 at 10:09 am

    Divorce & Family Law

    Our builder is wanting in order to influence us to advance for you to .internet from PHP. We have often disliked the thought because of the costs. But he’s tryiong not one your less. I have been employing Hubpages on the various websites for about a year and also feel worried about moving over to a different platform.

    Reply
  10. Divorce & Family Law says

    June 26, 2013 at 10:09 am

    Divorce & Family Law

    Our builder is wanting in order to influence us to advance for you to .internet from PHP. We have often disliked the thought because of the costs. But he’s tryiong not one your less. I have been employing Hubpages on the various websites for about a year and also feel worried about moving over to a different platform.

    Reply
  11. Divorce & Family Law says

    June 26, 2013 at 10:09 am

    Divorce & Family Law

    Our builder is wanting in order to influence us to advance for you to .internet from PHP. We have often disliked the thought because of the costs. But he’s tryiong not one your less. I have been employing Hubpages on the various websites for about a year and also feel worried about moving over to a different platform.

    Reply
  12. Divorce & Family Law says

    June 26, 2013 at 10:09 am

    Divorce & Family Law

    Our builder is wanting in order to influence us to advance for you to .internet from PHP. We have often disliked the thought because of the costs. But he’s tryiong not one your less. I have been employing Hubpages on the various websites for about a year and also feel worried about moving over to a different platform.

    Reply
  13. oAkLey SungLASSeS cheAp says

    July 9, 2013 at 8:44 am

    oAkLey SungLASSeS cheAp

    These all YouTube gaming video lessons are in fact in pleasant quality, I watched out all these along through my colleagues.

    Reply
  14. Best Oakley Sunglasses says

    July 11, 2013 at 8:39 pm

    Best Oakley Sunglasses

    Wow, fastidious YouTube video concerning how to establish virtual directory, I totally got it. Thanks keep it up.

    Reply
  15. chanel outlet says

    July 15, 2013 at 4:22 pm

    chanel outlet

    The coffee maker was Nespresso and was perfect for us. Room service breakfast was correct and at just about the time they said it would be. This hotel was perfect and we will be back for another time in Key West.

    Reply
  16. Fake Oakley Asian Fit says

    July 30, 2013 at 5:36 pm

    Fake Oakley Asian Fit

    crImmigration.com: Fla Supreme Ct: Padilla not retroactive; admonishment doesn’t cure bad advice

    Reply
  17. kereta mini says

    February 3, 2015 at 7:35 am

    crImmigration.com: Fla Supreme Ct: Padilla not retroactive; admonishment doesn’t cure bad advice

    Reply

Leave a Reply to nike air max sale Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe


Recent Posts

  • Supreme Court says gap in conviction records hurts migrant
  • Abolish ICE
  • Federal court enjoins 100-day deportation pause
  • ICE issues enforcement priorities
  • Immigration possibilities & challenges
  • Criminal bars, policing changes, & meaningful reforms in proposed legislation

Search

Social Media

Blawg 100 Honoree

The information contained on these pages must not be considered legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. This work by www.crImmigration.com is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.