The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit rejected the Attorney General’s decision in Matter of Silva-Trevino, 24 I&N Dec. 687 (A.G. 2008), expanding the analytical framework by which immigration courts determine whether an immigrant has been convicted of a crime involving moral turpitude. § 101(a)(48)(A). Id. at 6. The INA even includes a list of documents that “shall constitute proof of a conviction,” the court noted. Id. at 6 (citing INA § 240(c)(3)(B)). Nothing in the statute indicates that Congress intended for an IJ to rely on other evidence as proof of a conviction. Silva-Trevino, No. 11-60464, slip op. at 6.
Moreover, the Fifth Circuit explained that Congress is presumed to be aware of the traditional method for interpreting whether a conviction constitutes a removable offense, the categorical approach. Using the categorical approach, courts have consistently limited the type of evidence admissible for purposes of proving that a particular person was convicted of a removable offense. Despite that, Congress has never altered the conviction requirement to allow for consideration of other evidence even though it has routinely amended the CIMT provision. Id. at 9. The court, therefore, assumed that Congress expects it to continue using the categorical approach. Id.
This is a major victory for immigrants in removal proceedings within the Fifth Circuit. Meanwhile, the circuit split that Mukasey’s opinion created continues to grow. Only time will tell how that ends.
Hermes Outlet
The post is written in very a good manner and it entails much useful information for me.\nWith the built-in Google Maps navigation equipment, you can go anywhere you want. In 1992 Rolex made Birkin Bag Hermes Price luxury watch history by releasing the Yacht Master. Everyone knows that replica is a copy that is relatively the same as Hermes Birkin Black the original. The Rolex is known all over the world due to the high standards and excellent quality control. These top quality watches provide excellent performance, perfect innovation and reliable stability and that is the reason why Rolex replica watches are world widely respected by Hermes Birkin Orange their customers. You truly will know you’ve bought the right gift when you see it. These three places are Delhi, Agra and Jaipur. In the city of Jaipur tourists can visit Hawa Mahal, City Palace, Govind Templen Jal Mahaln Hermes Birkin Replica Price List Mubarak Palace Nahargarh fort, Jaigarh fort Amber Fort, Kanak Valley etc. Rajasthan Tour Package. This tour package offers the tourists a great opportunity to experience the land of the Kings which is Royal in it.